The Institute for Leisure Studies
  • Blog
  • Music
  • Merchandise
  • About
  • Touring Film History

Suicide, Economics, and Reason

4/25/2013

0 Comments

 
This article in Slate is interesting but too short, and it raises many questions.

That the lives of unsuccessful suicides become financially better after the attempt is interesting. They are often forced into psychiatric treatment that may have been unavailable to them before. It's worth considering how mental illness is a drain on society, since you have all these people (more suicides than murders and 20 times more attempted suicides than successful ones) living pained, disorganized lives. From a rational economic view, this may be a good case for more funding of public mental health.

Also, the Suicide Prevention movement has spent the last decades advocating that suicide must never be considered rational.
Constructing suicide as a momentary loss of reason is vitally important to the suicide-prevention movement because it suggests that men and women who have attempted self-murder should be allowed to shrug off social stigmas. If suicidal instincts are just momentary delusions, they are easily explained and dismissed. The suicide-prevention movement fears that if suicide is deemed the rational product of someone's mind, we may feel justified in suspecting that mind forever.
I understand why we would want to prevent people from being handicapped by a social stigma. Yet, it's obvious that suicide can be a rational decision. It's certainly not, as G.K. Chesterton said, "the ultimate and absolute evil, the refusal to take an interest in existence." I love Chesterton, but this is one of those times when his innate intelligence is warped by his Catholicism.

Interest in existence has its limits. Sometimes it's not worth the trouble. A rational view of death and suicide acknowledges that life ends sooner or later, and that some ends are preferable to others. However, many Americans seem to think life must be extended at all costs, and that death is something we succumb to after everything has been tried. This is stupid and causes unnecessary suffering.
0 Comments



Leave a Reply.

    Picture

    David Jordan

    David Jordan is the founder of the Institute for Leisure Studies and currently serves as Lead Researcher.

    Archives

    September 2014
    January 2014
    November 2013
    August 2013
    April 2013
    March 2013
    February 2013
    January 2013
    November 2012
    October 2012
    September 2012

    RSS Feed

    Podcasts!

    Affirmation Nation
    Against the Grain
    Alan Watts
    By the Way (Jeff Garlin)
    Comedy Bang Bang
    Counterspin
    The Cracked Podcast
    Democracy Now!
    Gelmania
    How Did This Get Made?
    Moyers and Co.
    Intelligence Squared
    The Phil Hendrie Podcast
    The Philosopher's Zone
    Philosophy Bites
    Point of Inquiry
    Quit It
    Rationally Speaking
    Real Time with Bill Maher
    Savage Lovecast
    The Smartest Man in the World
    Media Matters
    WTF with Marc Maron

    Blogs I Like
    In no particular order:

    BikeSnobNYC
    Sam Harris
    Metal Inquisition
    Radical Jew
    Gin and Tacos
    That's Not Metal
    Beat the Press
    Giammona Papers
    The Trailer Park Cyclist

Powered by Create your own unique website with customizable templates.